A Rant
A week of illness gives one time to be contemplative. Also, bored.
I've been surfing random LiveJournals. LiveJournal has a really nice update interface and all, but god, it has some morons posting there. Still, I thank them for using spelling options like "mah baybee" and so on; it's such a beautiful cue for "Hey! This person's a total fucking moron, and you should despise them and avoid contact with them!" Saves time.
#unisfa conversation has brought to mind a couple of things:
Post-primary school, teachers really shouldn't make students read things out loud. Those students who aren't good at it never will be, and those students who can do it smoothly and easily will find it really damned annoying.
Plays are fun, except when they can't pronounce the words in Shakespeare, or understand them, and whenever you do Romeo and Juliet some complete fucking moron always has to trot out that "wherefore art thou Romeo" "I'm over here" thing, and I'm sorry, people, but there's no comma in there, wherefore in less archaic terms translates to "why" not "where". Juliet's question is "why are you Romeo; a Montague and my enemy" not "where are you, and why are you STALKING ME".
Which brings us to plays I've hated: Romeo and Juliet I just disliked, because I found the protagonists to be not even vaguely sympathetic, I wanted to slap them both upside the head with a mallet.
Another one we did in High School was called No Sugar, by Jack Davis; I hated this one, too, for the following reasons:
- It's badly written, as a play. In terms of the staging requirements, it would make a passable film script, but as a play, it's impossible to do on a normal stage in the normal fashion.
- It's written as a historical play, but it's historically inaccurate. According to the events it references, there's a pregnancy in there that takes three years. My Lit teacher and I had long arguments about this; I still say that if you want to do a historical play, you're stuck with history, and it's incumbent upon you to DEAL WITH THAT.
- The plot is telegraphed and pedestrian. The characterisation is shoddy. The politics and general 'message' are unsubtle, where 'unsubtle' is defined as 'yes, we got it two acts ago, get on with it already'. Any kind of stylistic merit it might have retained is crushed by heavy-handed politics.
Another argument I used to have with my Lit teacher was about an Australian poet named Bruce Dawe. He loved Dawe; I scorn Dawe. He's written exactly two poems I think are well-written, and I still dislike one of those two a lot.
Damn it, just because we live in Australia, did we have to focus on Australian 'literature'? And if we did, why did we have to do the really shite stuff?
Especially "No Sugar". I have a lot of sympathy for the Aboriginal cause, but that play is positively counterproductive. After the second time we had to read through it, I was wavering on wishing Jack Davis' parents at least had been included in the massacre, just to save the world the pain of a bloody awful play that innocent people are forced to be exposed to out of sheer political correctness.
Really, I did hate it that much. Mind you, I hated Bruce Dawe, too, and not just because one of the two well-written poems mentioned above is extremely offensive politically. His. Poems. Suck.
I also didn't like reading Thomas Hardy. The Mayor of Casterbridge is one of the most boring books I've ever read; Tess of the D'urbervilles, ugh. I also hated Joseph Conrad's "Heart of Darkness" and lamented long that he didn't follow through on his impulse to write in French rather than English.
So what do you actually like, Rae?
Let's do a county thing.
5 Playwrights:
- Arthur Miller
- Ibsen
- Willy Russell
- Aristophanes
- Shakespeare
4 Poets
- ee cummings
- Edith Sodergran
- Gwen Harwood
- Alfred, Lord Tennyson
3 Plays
- A View From the Bridge (Arthur Miller)
- A Midsummer Night's Dream (Wm Shakespeare)
- Educating Rita (Willy Russell)
2 Poems
- somewhere i have never travelled (ee cumming)
- Ulysses (Alfred, Lord Tennyson)
1 Book That's Worth Studying At School
- The Great Gatsby
(Explanation on that one: It's not too long for those with busy school or social schedules, it's a good and enjoyable book, and it's really easy to write about, because it's positively overloaded with symbolism.)
And there you go
A week of illness gives one time to be contemplative. Also, bored.
I've been surfing random LiveJournals. LiveJournal has a really nice update interface and all, but god, it has some morons posting there. Still, I thank them for using spelling options like "mah baybee" and so on; it's such a beautiful cue for "Hey! This person's a total fucking moron, and you should despise them and avoid contact with them!" Saves time.
#unisfa conversation has brought to mind a couple of things:
Post-primary school, teachers really shouldn't make students read things out loud. Those students who aren't good at it never will be, and those students who can do it smoothly and easily will find it really damned annoying.
Plays are fun, except when they can't pronounce the words in Shakespeare, or understand them, and whenever you do Romeo and Juliet some complete fucking moron always has to trot out that "wherefore art thou Romeo" "I'm over here" thing, and I'm sorry, people, but there's no comma in there, wherefore in less archaic terms translates to "why" not "where". Juliet's question is "why are you Romeo; a Montague and my enemy" not "where are you, and why are you STALKING ME".
Which brings us to plays I've hated: Romeo and Juliet I just disliked, because I found the protagonists to be not even vaguely sympathetic, I wanted to slap them both upside the head with a mallet.
Another one we did in High School was called No Sugar, by Jack Davis; I hated this one, too, for the following reasons:
- It's badly written, as a play. In terms of the staging requirements, it would make a passable film script, but as a play, it's impossible to do on a normal stage in the normal fashion.
- It's written as a historical play, but it's historically inaccurate. According to the events it references, there's a pregnancy in there that takes three years. My Lit teacher and I had long arguments about this; I still say that if you want to do a historical play, you're stuck with history, and it's incumbent upon you to DEAL WITH THAT.
- The plot is telegraphed and pedestrian. The characterisation is shoddy. The politics and general 'message' are unsubtle, where 'unsubtle' is defined as 'yes, we got it two acts ago, get on with it already'. Any kind of stylistic merit it might have retained is crushed by heavy-handed politics.
Another argument I used to have with my Lit teacher was about an Australian poet named Bruce Dawe. He loved Dawe; I scorn Dawe. He's written exactly two poems I think are well-written, and I still dislike one of those two a lot.
Damn it, just because we live in Australia, did we have to focus on Australian 'literature'? And if we did, why did we have to do the really shite stuff?
Especially "No Sugar". I have a lot of sympathy for the Aboriginal cause, but that play is positively counterproductive. After the second time we had to read through it, I was wavering on wishing Jack Davis' parents at least had been included in the massacre, just to save the world the pain of a bloody awful play that innocent people are forced to be exposed to out of sheer political correctness.
Really, I did hate it that much. Mind you, I hated Bruce Dawe, too, and not just because one of the two well-written poems mentioned above is extremely offensive politically. His. Poems. Suck.
I also didn't like reading Thomas Hardy. The Mayor of Casterbridge is one of the most boring books I've ever read; Tess of the D'urbervilles, ugh. I also hated Joseph Conrad's "Heart of Darkness" and lamented long that he didn't follow through on his impulse to write in French rather than English.
So what do you actually like, Rae?
Let's do a county thing.
5 Playwrights:
- Arthur Miller
- Ibsen
- Willy Russell
- Aristophanes
- Shakespeare
4 Poets
- ee cummings
- Edith Sodergran
- Gwen Harwood
- Alfred, Lord Tennyson
3 Plays
- A View From the Bridge (Arthur Miller)
- A Midsummer Night's Dream (Wm Shakespeare)
- Educating Rita (Willy Russell)
2 Poems
- somewhere i have never travelled (ee cumming)
- Ulysses (Alfred, Lord Tennyson)
1 Book That's Worth Studying At School
- The Great Gatsby
(Explanation on that one: It's not too long for those with busy school or social schedules, it's a good and enjoyable book, and it's really easy to write about, because it's positively overloaded with symbolism.)
And there you go